This article is from the VW Technical FAQ, by with numerous contributions by Jan Vandenbrande others.
A: There are numerous causes for this. Most of the time the problem is fairly
trivial. Going from cheapest to most expensive, try the following:
See also charge light diagnosis below.
- Check the ground connections, possibly install a new ground from
alternator to battery rather than using the engine block/transmission as
conductor. Forget trying to find the bad connection with an Ohm meter: Say
your alt. puts out 50 Amps, you'll get a drop of 1 Volt for each .02 Ohm!!!
Most VOMeters are not accurate enough in this range.
So, those tiny little resistances that have build up over the years REALLY
add up.
Use a THICK (10 or less Gauge/"AWG"), multistrand wire.
- Check the alternator wiring harness. Same reason as above.
- Clean all related connectors (sand paper, file).
- SOLDER ALL crimped connectors
- Check for an unusual drain (unlikely but possible)
- Check/clean/replace the alternator brushes (easy, see wear limits in
Bentley).
- Check the battery water level (use distilled water)
NOTE: DO NOT ASSUME YOU HAVE A MAINTENANCE FREE BATTERY BECAUSE IT
DOES NOT HAVE LITTLE SCREW TOPS. MOST VW BATTERIES ARE NOT MAINTENANCE
FREE AND THE WATER LEVEL SHOULD BE CHECKED PERIODICALLY!
- Have the battery checked (it may be shorting out)
- Have the alternator checked (diodes and regulator may be bad). Alternator
replacement is by the way trivial. If the alternator is bad, upgrade to a
higher amp one, especially in older cars and if you have a powerful stereo
system or aux lights 90 amp replacements are the current "hot" ticket.
However, some of the upgrades require a different wiring harness.
ND for example sells these and calls them their "Massive Overkill"
wires.
EuroCar had a detailed procedure on this about 1 or 2 years ago.
NOTE: Many car parts places will check out your alternator for free
or a very low cost. Sears used to do it for free in the US if you had
a DieHard battery, now they charge some nominal amount.
- Replace battery connectors with better quality ones.
(From D.J. Stern: number 1 or number 2 gauge Whitaker brass-terminal
battery cables.)
 
Continue to: